| Robert Plummer | ||
|---|---|---|
| Year | Host/Site | Round |
| 2000 | Tipton | Sectional |
| 2001 | Bethany Christian | Sectional |
| 2002 | Fort Wayne Northrop | Sectional |
| 2003 | Warsaw | Sectional |
| 2004 | New Haven | Sectional |
| 2005 | Kokomo | Sectional |
| 2007 | Southern Wells | Sectional |
| NorthWood | Regional | |
| 2008 | DeKalb | Sectional |
| Marion | Regional | |
| 2009 | Fort Wayne Blackhawk | Sectional |
| Blackford | Regional | |
| 2010 | Harding | Sectional |
| Tipton | Regional | |
| 2011 | Garrett | Sectional |
| Lawrence Central | Regional | |
| Seymour | Semistate | |
| 2012 | DeKalb | Sectional |
| Connersville | Regional | |
| 2013 | Manchester | Sectional |
| Plymouth | Regional | |