| Herb Teal | ||
|---|---|---|
| Year | Host/Site | Round |
| 2008 | Martinsville | Sectional |
| 2009 | Noblesville | Sectional |
| 2012 | University | Sectional |
| 2013 | Carmel | Sectional |
| 2014 | University | Sectional |
| 2015 | Indianapolis Washington | Sectional |
| 2016 | Indianapolis Broad Ripple | Sectional |
| 2017 | Edingurgh | Sectional |
| 2018 | Beech Grove | Sectional |
| 2019 | Danville | Sectional |
| 2020 | Bethesda Christian | Sectional |
| 2021 | Mississinewa | Sectional |
| 2022 | South Putnam | Sectional |
| 2023 | Indianapolis Lutheran | Sectional |
| 2024 | Alexandria | Sectional |